Best Mattress Protector Reviews

Mattress ProtectorIf you aren’t periodically replacing your mattress protector, then you’re missing out on a chance to protect your sleeping environment in an innovative, and very affordable way. A mattress protector helps to protect your bed against spills, dust mites, and even bed bugs if it covers the entire bed. Many protectors are waterproof, yet easy enough to care for since you just throw them into the washing machine. If you don’t have a mattress protector, or your old one is looking like it has seen better days, then read on and discover the best products on the market right now.

The Best Chart For Mattress Protectors

Mattress protectors are made with many different materials and have several different designs. The chart below will help you quickly pick out the protectors that can best meet your needs.

PictureNameOur RatingPrice
Mattress Protector By Comfiy4.8$$
Sky Bedding Mattress Protector4.7$$
Coop Home Goods Waterproof Hypoallergenic Mattress Protector Pad4.7$$$
Hanna Kay Mattress Protector4.5$$$
Dreamaway Comfort Fill Mattress Protector4.3$$
Sleep Tite by Malouf Hypoallergenic 100% Waterproof Mattress Protector 4.3$$
Bella Sleep Mattress Protector4.7$$$
Felicibini Quilted Mattress Protector4.5$$
ExceptionalSheets Mattress Encasement Bed Bug Protector4.9$$$
Guardmax Bedbug Proof/Waterproof Mattress Protector Cover4.5$$$
PictureNameOur RatingPrice

What Is a Mattress Protector and Why Do I Need One? 

All it takes is one spill to ruin an expensive mattress. Mattress toppers are like a fitted sheet, but they are designed with a protective material that stops spills and other debris that could ruin your bed from entering into the mattress. Some protectors are even designed to encompass the entire mattress so you can protect yourself against bed bugs, dust mites, and other cohabiting critters that want to share your mattress.

Some mattresses come with their own type of protector attached with it, but not all of them are comfortable. It is not uncommon to find mattress protectors made from a cheap plastic that makes noise when you move in bed. If you’ve invested $500 into a memory foam mattress and it is the protector that is reflecting body heat back to you, squeaking when you roll over, and waking you up, then it’s time to invest into a higher quality protector.

The best mattress protector reviews will help you to find a product that fits your mattress properly. You’ll get to see what materials have been used to manufacture the protector and how good the durability of each product happens to be. It makes sense to protect your investment into a good night’s sleep and a mattress protector is the best way to make sure you can maximize the life of your mattress.

How To Find the Best Mattress Protector For Me

The best mattress protectors are designed to help prevent wear and tear on your mattress. They guard against stains and the shield against pests. Some are even equipped with a small amount of padding to help the sleeping experience be even more comfortable. In order to find the best mattress protector, the first step is to determine which type of this removal bedding is going to meet your needs.

  • Elastic. This type of protector is a lot like a fitted sheet. It slips on over your mattress and stays in place. It will protect you against threats from above the mattress, but won’t protect against threats from below the mattress.
  • Fitted. Like the elastic mattress protector, this type fits on top of the mattress like your sheets. Without the elastic, however, this type of protector tends to slip off a little more easily than its counterparts. It also tends to be a little cheaper than other types of protectors.
  • Zippered. This is the type of mattress protector which provides the maximum level of protection. You slip the mattress into the cover and then zipper the protector closed around it. Think of it like a sleeping bag for your mattress. 

If you want complete protection, then you need a zippered mattress protector. There’s no getting around that fact. If you’re just guarding against the occasional spill or accident that happens on a mattress, then the other options will get the job done for a smaller investment. 

What Are the Advantages of the Best Mattress Protectors? 

It’s easy to think that a fitted sheet can help to protect a mattress, but a thin layer of material will not stop fluids or stains whatsoever. That’s what a mattress protector can do. It keeps stains from getting on a mattress and helps to make sure that it stays clean and dry. The best protectors also add an extra level of support and comfort to the sleeping experience.

Zippered mattress protectors can also help to stop a bed bug infestation from spreading if the mattress is sealed properly. You’ll need to keep the protector on the mattress for at least 1 year to make sure the infestation has been cleared.

What you’re ultimately doing with an investment into a mattress protector is giving yourself the chance to increase the lifespan of your mattress. When some premium brand mattresses can exceed $5,000 in price, the need to get the maximum amount of life out of the bed is essential for many households today. Since this product is so affordable, it just makes sense to spend a little more so that you get a lot more life out of your new bed.

What Are the Prices of the Best Mattress Protectors? 

You’re going to be able to find most mattress protectors are around the $50 price point. There are several options that are below this price, but each tends to come with a certain disadvantage. They could be made from a cheaper plastic, not provide full protection over the surface of the mattress, or be 100% waterproof. That’s why it is important to look at every feature in the best mattress protector reviews to make sure a product can meet your needs.

Many of the mattress protectors that are above $50 tend to offer premium benefits. You might receive extra padding, thicker protection that covers the entire mattress, or easy-care options that let you run the protector through the washer and dryer.

What Do Our Reviews Have To Say? 


This mattress protector is guaranteed to provide protection against fluids, bacteria, and dust mites. It’s cool and breathable, which makes the sleeping experience much more comfortable. It also doesn’t make that “plastic” noise when you crawl into bed, which is another definite plus. It’s an elastic cover that fits nicely on your mattress and stays put, even if you toss and turn. It’s machine washable as well, but you’ll want to hang this one out to dry. For the price, you can’t go wrong with the benefits this mattress protector is able to provide.

Click here to look at pricing on Amazon and find a great deal.

Coop Home Goods

If you’re looking for a premium mattress protector without the premium price tag, then consider this rayon bamboo option for your bed. It protects against spills and even your perspiration at night so that your mattress warranty isn’t voided. This protector will fit mattresses up to 18 inches in height and it is hypoallergenic so you can get some good rest. A 15 year warranty protects your investment and you get a no questions 30 day money back guarantee on this comfortable product.

Click here to look at pricing on Amazon and find a great deal.

Hanna Kay

This fitted-style mattress protector offers a maximum level of versatility, working on mattresses as thin as 6 inches in height or as thick as 22 inches. It will protect your mattress against any liquid stain that could happen and also offers allergen protection as well. We really loved the feel of this mattress protector because it is similar to the top of the bed itself, making the transition to sleeping on it smooth and easy. It won’t protect the side of your mattress, but if there are threats from the top, it will do a good job.

Click here to look at pricing on Amazon and find a great deal.

Exceptional Sheets

This is the mattress protector for you if you want 100% protection for your mattress. It complete encases the mattress with a 3-sided zipper system that makes it really easy to install. Just lift up your mattress, slip the base of this protector underneath it, and then zip it up. It’s very lightweight and it even protects against mold and mildew penetration for those climates that see a lot of moisture. You’ll need to specify whether you need a shallow, medium, or deep cover upon ordering. Crib protectors are also available upon request.

Click here to look at pricing on Amazon and find a great deal.


The advantage of this particular mattress protector is that it provides a superior level of quiet. Those plastic crinkling and sliding sounds that other products provide don’t exist with this one. It isn’t going to tear or crack with consistent use either. You can use your washer and dryer to clean this cover, though taking it off the mattress to do so may not be a good idea if you’re trying to deal with some bed bugs. It’s made from 100% polyester and it has a polyurethane backing. Be careful with the zippers and let the plastic breathe for a day or two before putting on the bed.

Click here to look at pricing on Amazon and find a great deal.

The best mattress protector reviews will help you find the right way to enhance the investment you’ve made into your bed. You deserve a good night of rest. The right mattress protector can help to make sure your bed can keep doing that for as long as possible.

Related Posts